Problems
Troubleshooting
When a customer says they did not get your email, the urge is to change something straight away. It is better to calmly work out first at which stage the message got lost: it was never sent, it was rejected, or it was accepted but put in spam. Below are common situations and a sequence of steps for when emails stop arriving. The cause can almost always be found in the message headers and the domain's records.
Before changing anything, get hold of at least one problem message and look at its headers: the answer is often already there.
How this section works: causes are described in general terms. If the problem persists after all the steps, contact the support team of whoever manages your domain or email and attach the headers of the problem message.
Common situations
Emails go to spam. Where do I start?
Open the headers of such a message and look at the results of the SPF, DKIM and DMARC checks. If one of them failed, start there. If all passed, the cause is more likely reputation: recipient complaints, messages to non-existent addresses, or content that looks like bulk mail sent without consent.
Emails stopped arriving after a change of hosting
During a move the website is often transferred but the email records are forgotten: the old SPF record points to a server you no longer use, the DKIM key was not carried over, and the records responsible for receiving mail lead nowhere. Compare the records before and after the move using your change log and restore the missing ones.
Mailings get through but ordinary emails do not
That means the mailing service is set up correctly but your main email is not. Check that the server behind your work mailboxes is listed in the SPF record and that DKIM signing is turned on for your main email. It can also be the other way round, so check each sender separately.
Recipients see “on behalf of” or “via”
This is how mail services show that a message was sent with your address but signed or sent by someone else's domain, usually a third-party service. Set up DKIM signing on your own domain for that service and, if the service allows it, your own return address.
The DKIM signature fails the check
Most often the key in the TXT record was copied with a mistake or split into parts incorrectly, the record was added under the wrong name, or it is not yet visible. Compare the record with what your mail service's panel gave you. The signature also breaks when a message is altered on the way, for example when text is added at the bottom.
DMARC reports arrive but make no sense
The reports are designed for machine processing. Use a tool that collects them into a table and focus on the essentials: which sources send email in your name and whether they pass the checks. Unfamiliar sources that fail are usually the forgeries; familiar ones that fail are a gap in your own setup.
If emails stop arriving
Work out the scope
Are emails failing to reach everyone, or only recipients at one mail service? Only from one mailbox or from the whole domain? The answer immediately narrows the search.
Check the domain
Make sure the domain registration has not expired and that the DNS settings are in place. An unpaid domain stops working entirely, email included.
Find the error message
If the message bounced with a non-delivery notice, read it carefully: it usually states the reason for rejection on the recipient's side.
Look at the headers
Ask the recipient to forward the message from their spam folder as an attachment, or send a test message to yourself and check the SPF, DKIM and DMARC results.
Check your log
Think about what has changed in recent days: a website move, a new mailing service, edits to records. Most often the problem starts with the latest change.
Fix it and wait
After editing records, give them time to become visible, then run the check again. Do not weaken your protection wholesale: look for the specific sender whose setup is incomplete.
Read next
- Guides
Step-by-step walkthroughs: tidying up your domain's email in a day, your first DMARC record, shared mailboxes, a leaving employee. Plus the article catalogue.
- Tools
What to keep at hand: access to DNS settings, a list of all senders, record checks, DMARC reports, message headers and a change log.
- Comparisons
How SPF, DKIM and DMARC differ, an address on your own domain versus a free mailbox, and DMARC modes from monitoring to rejection.
- Security
Fake payment requests, lookalike domains, shared passwords, former employees' access, dangerous attachments and forwarding to personal mailboxes.
- Glossary
Key terms in plain words: domain, DNS, TXT record, SPF, DKIM, DMARC, sender reputation, spam complaint and headers.
Sources
- RFC 7208 — Sender Policy Framework
- RFC 6376 — DomainKeys Identified Mail
- RFC 7489 — DMARC
- Requirements of large mailbox providers for bulk senders (2024)
- Editorial materials of this guide
The texts in this guide describe email records and settings in general terms; they are accurate as of the preparation date shown on each page. Domain and email control panels differ, call the same options by different names and change their menus from time to time. If the hints in your panel differ from our description, follow your panel and the help pages of whoever manages your domain.